Garnet Redraw First Attempt

When I thought about redrawing Garnet for that "Draw This again Meme" this was actually my first attempt at redrawing her.

To me she looks kinda stubby, so I scrapped this then attempted again and what you saw on my actual meme was my second attempt, only that time I tried to not make her look stubby. lol

Anyway, I'm just posting this to get your thoughts on it, cause some of my friends thought this was better.

So, what do you guys think?